Being that it's complicated, it's a long story. Better authors have written entire books about the subject so I will strive to provide only enough information to give context to the events around the 1979 NHL Expansion Draft.
The Oilers, Whalers, Nordiques and Jets were not really expansion teams (in much the same way the California Seals and Vancouver Canucks weren't really expansion teams either, but I'll save those stories for another time). They were members of another league before joining the NHL: the World Hockey Association.
The WHA was an entirely new league founded in 1971 by Gary Davidson and Dennis Murphy. Their purpose was to directly challenge the NHL's supremacy over all the other hockey leagues in North America. To accomplish that goal they sold franchises to businessmen in cities that weren't considered suitable for NHL expansion in the late '60s and early '70s, including cities like Cleveland, Edmonton, Houston, Miami, Ottawa, Quebec City and Winnipeg. Some of these teams never took to the ice (Miami), some failed within a year or two (Ottawa), and some lasted more than a couple years but ultimately moved or folded (Cleveland, Houston).
Murphy and Davidson were not new to this sort of thing. They founded the American Basketball Association in 1967, a league which would compete directly with the National Basketball Association for supremacy in pro basketball. Arguably they were following the lead of the American Football League, founded in 1959 to challenge the established National Football League. The AFL and NFL agreed to merge in 1966 and in effect the AFL's club owners had insinuated themselves into NFL membership without having to pay exorbitant expansion fees. The idea behind the ABA and WHA was the same: establish a new league, compete with the old league, and eventually merge with the old league.
The ABA merged with the NBA in 1976, with four of the ABA clubs in effect joining the NBA. The leagues had pursued merger negotiations as early as 1970 however they were unable to effect a merger because of a lawsuit filed by player Oscar Robertson, who contended that a merged ABA and NBA would be a monopoly on pro basketball and would violate anti-trust legislation. (The NFL-AFL merger was exempted from US anti-trust legislation by US congressional approval, and Major League Baseball has had a long-standing exemption.)
The AFL-NFL merger was essentially a merger of equals, with neither league really having the upper hand over the other (save for territorial indemnifications the AFL's Raiders owed the NFL's 49ers and AFL's Jets owed the NFL's Giants). The ABA-NBA merger clearly favoured the NBA—two ABA teams were paid to fold and the ABA teams that joined the NBA accepted several caveats such as not being able to vote on certain matters at league meetings and not receiving income from the pooled television contract revenues for a period of time—but the ABA-NBA relationship was not particularly acrimonious. Not like the NHL and WHA.
There was outright hostility between the NHL and WHA. They took each other to court several times in the first few years of the WHA's existence over player rights. Competition with the WHA directly and indirectly affected NHL policies and business plans throughout the 1970s. Merger negotiations between the two leagues began as early as 1973 however serious negotiations wouldn't happen until after Clarence Campbell stepped down as NHL President and John Ziegler replaced him in 1977. The WHA had caused player salaries in the NHL to rise dramatically and this rise in the cost of doing business was threatening the existence of several NHL clubs. By 1978 the Barons and North Stars were at immediate risk of folding altogether but one was saved at the expense of the other in a last-minute agreement to merge the two franchises. (See the 1978 NHL Dispersal Draft.)
In the spring of 1979, after long negotiation sessions between the two leagues' representatives, they finally came to an agreement to merge. The WHA's Edmonton Oilers, New England Whalers, Quebec Nordiques and Winnipeg Jets would join the NHL for the 1979-80 NHL season. The WHA's other remaining teams, the Birmingham Bulls and Cincinnati Stingers, would be indemnified for their exclusion and fold at the end of the 1978-79 WHA season.
The NHL owners were very particular about calling this an 'expansion' instead of a 'merger' because their 1975 collective bargaining agreement with the NHLPA contained a termination clause which would have gone into effect if the WHA 'merged' with the NHL.
The competition between the WHA and NHL in signing players had dramatically increased the average salary of pro hockey players and losing the WHA meant the players would lose the threat of 'defection' to the WHA as a bargaining chip in contract negotiations. If the collective bargaining agreement was terminated and a new one had to be negotiated the players wanted an end to restricted free agency (a prickly subject at the time; refer to the court case between the NHL and Dale McCourt mentioned below). In exchange for not terminating the CBA and more heavily pursuing an end to restricted free agency NHLPA Executive Director Alan Eagleson made overtures in the press about seeking half of the $24 million worth of expansion fees being charged to the Oilers, Whalers, Nordiques and Jets but ultimately the NHLPA settled for a modest bump in pension funding. (Players being transferred as compensation for free agent signings continued in the NHL until well into the 1990s.)
Being that these four new clubs were 'expansion' teams the NHL teams would be able to reclaim the rights of players who had 'defected' to the WHA as they saw fit, thus depleting the WHA teams' rosters and necessitating an 'expansion' draft to restock them. The expansion draft would also be used as justification for levying $6 million "expansion fees" from each of the WHA clubs. The Stingers would receive $3.2 million indemnification to fold, while the Bulls would receive $2.85 million; these indemnifications would be collectively paid by the Oilers, Whalers, Nordiques and Jets. The three new Canadian clubs would not receive revenue from the Hockey Night in Canada contract with the CBC for five seasons. The new clubs would be placed last in the draft order at the NHL Amateur Draft (which would later be renamed "Entry Draft" due to the fact several players that were eligible for selection had been playing professionally in the WHA). The league would play a balanced schedule: each team would play each other four times, regardless of divisional alignment (this was a concession to get the Vancouver Canucks to agree to the merger).
Supposedly one of the conditions of the agreement, imposed by the Boston Bruins, was that the New England Whalers change their name to Hartford Whalers. I haven't found a contemporary source to substantiate that; at the time (May 24, 1979) Whalers owner Howard Baldwin said the name change was made because of the support the citizens of Hartford had shown the Whalers since leaving Boston in 1974, the "idea of being in a capital city" and "a desire of the club to assure the area that the Whalers will be permanently based in Hartford". That last reason makes sense given the context that the Whalers were temporarily playing in Springfield, Massachusetts at the time because the roof of the Hartford Civic Center collapsed in 1978. They wouldn't return to Hartford until February, 1980. The idea that the Bruins insisted that the Whalers change their branding makes for an interesting story but as far as I can tell it's a tall tale. Besides, the Bruins were one of three dissenting NHL teams who did not agree to the merger. The merger approval vote at the NHL Board of Governors meeting required three-fourths majority, or 13 out of 17 clubs, and it was approved by a margin of 14 to three: the Bruins, Maple Leafs and Kings were the three dissenting votes. The Whalers didn't need to appease the Bruins.
The WHA would hold a dispersal draft after the 1978-79 season to disperse the players still under contract by the Bulls and Stingers to the four clubs joining the NHL. The WHA clubs would retain the rights to players that none of the existing NHL clubs laid claim. Players whose "NHL rights" were held by an existing NHL club could be 'reclaimed' by the NHL club from the WHA club with no compensation to the WHA club. The only exception to this was that the WHA club could make up to four "priority selections": they could pick up to two goaltenders and two other players whose rights were being reclaimed by an NHL club and retain those players' rights (the WHA club's claims would "take priority" over the NHL club's). A specific exemption was written into the merger agreement for Gordie Howe; he would not be eligible for reclaim and his rights would stay with the Whalers.
The rules of the expansion draft were:
- the NHL clubs would each protect 15 skaters and two goaltenders,
- if an NHL club lost more than one player as a "priority selection" then the number of players that NHL club could protect would be increased by the same. For example if NHL team 'X' lost two players as priority selections they could protect 16 skaters in the expansion draft, and would only lose three players in the expansion draft. If team 'X' lost three players as priority selections then they would protect 17 skaters, and only lose two players in the expansion draft.
- the NHL teams could only lose up to four players (barring the exemptions caused by priority selections explained above). Being that there were 17 NHL clubs and four 'expansion' clubs the draft would last 17 rounds.
- each selection would cost the 'expansion' club $125,000 (to be deducted from the $6 million expansion fee),
- each selection would be followed by a fill-in choice by the NHL club that lost a player,
- Dale McCourt would be exempted from the draft altogether. He would not be eligible for claim by an expansion club nor would he have to be protected by the club that held his rights. This was due to uncertainties surrounding the rights to McCourt as a result of the lawsuit he filed against the NHL, NHLPA, Los Angeles Kings and Detroit Red Wings in 1978 (McCourt v. California Sports, Inc., 460 F. Supp. 904 - Dist. Court, ED Michigan 1978). After an arbitrator awarded him to the Kings as compensation for the Red Wings' free agent signing of Rogie Vachon McCourt won an injunction to stay with the Red Wings, but the NHL appealed and the case was still under appeal at the time the merger was agreed to. (The NHL won the appeal and the verdict was handed down in May 1979, before the expansion draft, but McCourt's exemption from the draft stayed in place. McCourt was ultimately traded back to the Red Wings by the Kings before the 1979-80 season began, and in effect it was as though McCourt was never transferred to the Kings in the first place.)
WHA Dispersal Draft
The WHA's Dispersal Draft, the league's final act to disperse the defunct Cincinnati Stingers and Birmingham Bulls players among the four surviving clubs, took place on June 1, 1979. I haven't been able to find a detailed list of rules but I have found sources that say Robbie Ftorek went first overall to the Quebec Nordiques as a "bonus pick". What that means precisely I don't know. I suspect it may have had to do with the fact that Ftorek was one of the WHA's star players and he had a long, well-paying contract. Perhaps the teams agreed that Ftorek would go to whomever volunteered to take on his salary. The first round of selections was reportedly Bob Stephenson to the Whalers, Mike Liut to the Oilers, Barry Melrose to the Nordiques and Peter Marsh to the Jets, in that order. The full list of players chosen is as follows. They are in no particular order. The player's former team is noted in parentheses; '(B)' for Birmingham Bulls, '(C)' for Cincinnati Stingers and '(I)' for Indianapolis Racers. Reportedly Dave Fortier, Bruce Greig and Al McLeod of the defunct Indianapolis Racers were also included in the proceedings, despite the remaining Racers players being declared free agents when the team folded in December, 1978. As far as I know Fortier and McLeod never played pro hockey again after 1978-79 while Greig reported to the Edmonton Oilers' IHL affiliate in Dayton for '79-'80. He never played in the NHL again.
Edmonton Oilers | Hartford Whalers | Quebec Nordiques | Winnipeg Jets |
---|---|---|---|
Mike Liut (C) | Bob Stephenson (B) | Robbie Ftorek (C) | Peter Marsh (C) |
Bryon Baltimore (C) | Byron Shutt (C) | Barry Melrose (C) | Jamie Hislop (C) |
Reg Thomas (C) | Steve Alley (B) | Bill Gilligan (C) | Barry Legge (C) |
Bryan Watson (C) | Tony Cassolato (B) | Paul Stewart (C) | Craig Norwich (C) |
Dave Forbes (C) | Paul Henderson (B) | Michel Dion (C) | |
Kelly Davis (C) | Al McLeod (I) | Dave Dornseif (C) | |
Michel Parizeau (C) | Peter Marrin (B) | ||
Dave Fortier (I) | Greg Tebbutt (B) | ||
Bruce Greig (I) | John C. Stewart (B) |
Several other Bulls and Stingers players weren't included and were declared eligible for the 1979 NHL Entry Draft, including the Bulls' Rob Ramage, Rick Vaive, Michel Goulet, Gaston Gingras and Pat Riggin, and the Stingers' Mike Gartner and Mark Messier. These players had not been drafted by any NHL teams before and were still of 'junior' age.
NHL Reclamation
About 100 of the four WHA teams' players had their rights held by an NHL team by virtue of having been drafted or having played for the NHL team in the past. The following is as complete a list as I could compile of the WHA players whose rights were also owned by an NHL team prior to the expansion draft and player reclamation. These are the players who could have been reclaimed by their respective NHL clubs. (Former WHA teams prior to the WHA dispersal are noted in parentheses where applicable.)
Player | NHL team | WHA team |
---|---|---|
Dale Hoganson | Atlanta Flames | Quebec Nordiques |
Kent Nilsson | Atlanta Flames | Winnipeg Jets |
Jeff Brubaker | Boston Bruins | Hartford Whalers |
George Buat | Boston Bruins | Edmonton Oilers |
Mark Howe | Boston Bruins | Hartford Whalers |
Rich Leduc | Boston Bruins | Quebec Nordiques |
Ron Plumb | Boston Bruins | Hartford Whalers |
Dave Dryden | Buffalo Sabres | Edmonton Oilers |
Al Hamilton | Buffalo Sabres | Edmonton Oilers |
François Lacombe | Buffalo Sabres | Quebec Nordiques |
Steve Alley | Chicago Black Hawks | Hartford Whalers (Birmingham Bulls) |
Real Cloutier | Chicago Black Hawks | Quebec Nordiques |
Dave Debol | Chicago Black Hawks | Cincinnati Stingers |
John Garrett | Chicago Black Hawks | Hartford Whalers |
Bobby Hull | Chicago Black Hawks | Winnipeg Jets (retired) |
Andre Lacroix | Chicago Black Hawks | Hartford Whalers |
Floyd Lahache | Chicago Black Hawks | Cincinnati Stingers |
Terry Ruskowski | Chicago Black Hawks | Winnipeg Jets |
Reg Thomas | Chicago Black Hawks | Quebec Nordiques (Cincinnati Stingers) |
Doug Berry | Colorado Rockies | Edmonton Oilers |
Paul Terbenche | Colorado Rockies | Winnipeg Jets |
Wes George | Detroit Red Wings | Edmonton Oilers |
Pierre Guité | Detroit Red Wings | Edmonton Oilers |
Glenn Hicks | Detroit Red Wings | Winnipeg Jets |
Gordie Howe1 | Detroit Red Wings | Hartford Whalers |
Marty Howe | Detroit Red Wings | Hartford Whalers |
Barry Long | Detroit Red Wings | Winnipeg Jets |
George Lyle | Detroit Red Wings | Hartford Whalers |
Bryon Baltimore | Los Angeles Kings | Edmonton Oilers (Cincinnati Stingers) |
Serge Bernier | Los Angeles Kings | Quebec Nordiques |
Steve Carlson | Los Angeles Kings | Edmonton Oilers |
Blair MacDonald | Los Angeles Kings | Edmonton Oilers |
Joe Daley | Minnesota North Stars | Winnipeg Jets |
Eddie Mio | Minnesota North Stars | Edmonton Oilers |
Cal Sandbeck | Minnesota North Stars | Edmonton Oilers |
Dave Semenko | Minnesota North Stars | Edmonton Oilers |
Paul Shmyr | Minnesota North Stars | Edmonton Oilers |
Greg Tebbutt | Minnesota North Stars | Quebec Nordiques (Birmingham Bulls) |
Tom Webster | Minnesota North Stars | Hartford Whalers |
Ron Carter | Montreal Canadiens | Edmonton Oilers |
Alain Côté | Montreal Canadiens | Quebec Nordiques |
Richard David | Montreal Canadiens | Quebec Nordiques |
Dan Geoffrion | Montreal Canadiens | Quebec Nordiques |
Alan Hanglesben | Montreal Canadiens | Hartford Whalers |
Jamie Hislop | Montreal Canadiens | Winnipeg Jets (Cincinnati Stingers) |
Dave Hunter | Montreal Canadiens | Edmonton Oilers |
Pierre Lagacé | Montreal Canadiens | Quebec Nordiques |
Barry Legge | Montreal Canadiens | Winnipeg Jets (Cincinnati Stingers) |
Chuck Luksa | Montreal Canadiens | Cincinnati Stingers2 |
Peter Marrin | Montreal Canadiens | Quebec Nordiques (Birmingham Bulls) |
Peter Marsh | Montreal Canadiens | Winnipeg Jets (Cincinnati Stingers) |
Barry Melrose | Montreal Canadiens | Quebec Nordiques (Cincinnati Stingers) |
Joe Micheletti | Montreal Canadiens | Edmonton Oilers |
Craig Norwich | Montreal Canadiens | Winnipeg Jets (Cincinnati Stingers) |
Gordie Roberts | Montreal Canadiens | Hartford Whalers |
Louis Sleigher | Montreal Canadiens | Birmingham Bulls3 |
John C. Stewart | Montreal Canadiens | Quebec Nordiques (Birmingham Bulls) |
Marc Tardif | Montreal Canadiens | Quebec Nordiques |
J.C. Tremblay | Montreal Canadiens | Quebec Nordiques |
Jim Turkewicz | Montreal Canadiens | Birmingham Bulls4 |
Dale Yakiwchuk | Montreal Canadiens | Winnipeg Jets |
Richard Brodeur | New York Islanders | Quebec Nordiques |
Kelly Davis | New York Islanders | Edmonton Oilers (Cincinnati Stingers) |
Dave Inkpen | New York Islanders | Hartford Whalers |
Dave Langevin | New York Islanders | Edmonton Oilers |
Garry Lariviere | New York Islanders | Quebec Nordiques |
Markus Mattsson | New York Islanders | Winnipeg Jets |
Jim Dorey | New York Rangers | Quebec Nordiques |
Jim Mayer | New York Rangers | Edmonton Oilers |
Warren Miller | New York Rangers | Hartford Whalers |
Jim Warner | New York Rangers | Hartford Whalers |
Serge Beaudoin | Philadelphia Flyers | Birmingham Bulls5 |
Ron Chipperfield | Philadelphia Flyers | Edmonton Oilers |
John McKenzie | Philadelphia Flyers | Hartford Whalers |
Dennis Sobchuk | Philadelphia Flyers | Edmonton Oilers |
Michel Parizeau | Philadelphia Flyers | Edmonton Oilers6 (Cincinnati Stingers) |
Paul Baxter | Pittsburgh Penguins | Quebec Nordiques |
Kim Clackson | Pittsburgh Penguins | Winnipeg Jets |
Morris Lukowich | Pittsburgh Penguins | Winnipeg Jets |
Byron Shutt | Pittsburgh Penguins | Hartford Whalers (Cincinnati Stingers) |
Christian Bordeleau | St. Louis Blues | Quebec Nordiques |
Scott Campbell | St. Louis Blues | Winnipeg Jets |
Dave Dornseif | St. Louis Blues | Quebec Nordiques (Cincinnati Stingers) |
Mike Liut | St. Louis Blues | Edmonton Oilers (Cincinnati Stingers) |
Risto Siltanen | St. Louis Blues | Edmonton Oilers |
Ernie Wakely | St. Louis Blues | Birmingham Bulls7 |
Jordy Douglas | Toronto Maple Leafs | Hartford Whalers |
Peter Driscoll | Toronto Maple Leafs | Edmonton Oilers |
Paul Henderson | Toronto Maple Leafs | Birmingham Bulls8 |
Rick Ley | Toronto Maple Leafs | Hartford Whalers |
Larry Pleau | Toronto Maple Leafs | Hartford Whalers |
Stan Weir | Toronto Maple Leafs | Edmonton Oilers |
John Hughes | Vancouver Canucks | Edmonton Oilers |
Mike Rogers | Vancouver Canucks | Hartford Whalers |
Bengt-Åke Gustafsson | Washington Capitals | Edmonton Oilers |
Paul MacKinnon | Washington Capitals | Winnipeg Jets |
Steve West | Washington Capitals | Winnipeg Jets |
1. Gordie Howe, as explained previously, was not eligible for reclaim as a condition of the merger agreement.
2. Chuck Luksa went unclaimed in the WHA dispersal draft. His contract was picked up by the Whalers on Aug. 15, 1979.
3. Louis Sleigher went unclaimed in the WHA dispersal draft. NHL sources say he was signed as a free agent by the Nordiques on Sept. 11, 1980, however he played a couple games for the Nordiques in '79-'80 and played the rest of that season with the Nordiques' top affiliate, the AHL's Syracuse Firebirds. I presume he signed a deal in 1979.
4. Jim Turkiewicz went unclaimed in the WHA dispersal draft. He tried out with the Buffalo Sabres at their '79 training camp, and played the season in the AHL for the Sabres' affiliate, the Rochester Americans.
5. Serge Beaudoin went unclaimed in the WHA dispersal draft. He signed as a free agent with the Atlanta Flames, Aug. 6, 1979.
6. Michel Parizeau retired as a player. He was named head coach of the AHL's Syracuse Firebirds on Sept. 6, 1979.
7. Ernie Wakely retired after the '78-'79 season.
8. Paul Henderson went unclaimed in the WHA dispersal draft. He signed as a free agent with the Atlanta Flames.
The following players were reclaimed on June 9, 1979. Priority selections are highlighted in green.
Player | Reclaimed by | from |
---|---|---|
Kent Nilsson | Atlanta Flames | Winnipeg Jets |
Mark Howe | Boston Bruins | Hartford Whalers |
Dave Dryden | Buffalo Sabres | Edmonton Oilers |
John Garrett | Chicago Black Hawks | Hartford Whalers |
Bobby Hull | Chicago Black Hawks | Winnipeg Jets |
Terry Ruskowski | Chicago Black Hawks | Winnipeg Jets |
Doug Berry | Colorado Rockies | Edmonton Oilers |
Wes George | Detroit Red Wings | Edmonton Oilers |
Glenn Hicks | Detroit Red Wings | Winnipeg Jets |
Barry Long | Detroit Red Wings | Winnipeg Jets |
George Lyle | Detroit Red Wings | Hartford Whalers |
Steve Carlson | Los Angeles Kings | Edmonton Oilers |
Eddie Mio | Minnesota North Stars | Edmonton Oilers |
Cal Sandbeck | Minnesota North Stars | Edmonton Oilers |
Dave Semenko | Minnesota North Stars | Edmonton Oilers |
Paul Shmyr | Minnesota North Stars | Edmonton Oilers |
Greg Tebbutt | Minnesota North Stars | Quebec Nordiques |
Alain Côté | Montreal Canadiens | Quebec Nordiques |
Dan Geoffrion | Montreal Canadiens | Quebec Nordiques |
Alan Hanglesben | Montreal Canadiens | Hartford Whalers |
Peter Marsh | Montreal Canadiens | Winnipeg Jets |
Richard Brodeur | New York Islanders | Quebec Nordiques |
Kelly Davis | New York Islanders | Edmonton Oilers |
Dave Langevin | New York Islanders | Edmonton Oilers |
Garry Lariviere | New York Islanders | Quebec Nordiques |
Markus Mattsson | New York Islanders | Winnipeg Jets |
Jim Mayer | New York Rangers | Edmonton Oilers |
Warren Miller | New York Rangers | Hartford Whalers |
Dennis Sobchuk | Philadelphia Flyers | Edmonton Oilers |
Paul Baxter | Pittsburgh Penguins | Quebec Nordiques |
Kim Clackson | Pittsburgh Penguins | Winnipeg Jets |
Morris Lukowich | Pittsburgh Penguins | Winnipeg Jets |
Christian Bordeleau | St. Louis Blues | Quebec Nordiques |
Scott Campbell | St. Louis Blues | Winnipeg Jets |
Mike Liut | St. Louis Blues | Edmonton Oilers |
Risto Siltanen | St. Louis Blues | Edmonton Oilers |
Jordy Douglas | Toronto Maple Leafs | Hartford Whalers |
Rick Ley | Toronto Maple Leafs | Hartford Whalers |
Stan Weir | Toronto Maple Leafs | Edmonton Oilers |
John Hughes | Vancouver Canucks | Edmonton Oilers |
Bengt-Åke Gustafsson | Washington Capitals | Edmonton Oilers1 |
Paul MacKinnon | Washington Capitals | Winnipeg Jets |
Wayne Gretzky | (none)2 | Edmonton Oilers |
1. The Oilers' priority claim over Bengt Gustafsson was challenged by the Capitals. The Capitals' appeal to President John Ziegler was ultimately successful and Gustafsson was transferred to the Capitals on Sept. 15, 1979.
2. No NHL team had any 'rights' to Wayne Gretzky, however the Oilers made him one of their priority selections anyway. The Oilers made this claim to assert their rights to Gretzky and prevent him from being eligible for selection in the Entry Draft. Complicating matters was the fact that Gretzky didn't have a contract with the Edmonton Oilers Hockey Club: his contract was with owner Peter Pocklington himself.
There are a few players who are erroneously named as 'reclaims' by a few of the typical sources out there, notably the NHL itself. Brad Selwood for instance was not reclaimed by the Canadiens from the Whalers. He had played for the Whalers since their inception in 1972. Prior to that he played in Toronto, and was a compensatory claim by the Canadiens in the 1972 NHL Intra-League Draft. Selwood announced his retirement from the Whalers on January 30, 1979. About six weeks later, March 13, he signed a contract with the Canadiens. He never played a game for them: he was traded to the Kings that September, before the '79-'80 season began.
Another such player is Rich Preston. Preston played for the Jets, and was in fact the final WHA playoff MVP. He was quoted in the papers as having taken to a microphone at centre ice after the Jets were presented the Avco World Trophy and gave a rousing speech to the Winnipeg fans. However, after the season, he became a free agent. As much as he appreciated the Jets' fan support it didn't pay the bills. He signed a contract with the Black Hawks. The Jets were keen on keeping him and Terry Ruskowski, two of their better young players, however Ruskowski was reclaimed by those same Black Hawks. So too was Bobby Hull, who had retired from the Jets early in the '78-'79 season. According to the papers of the time Jets GM John Ferguson had planned to let the Hawks reclaim Hull (whom the Hawks had been in negotiations with after he retired from the Jets) in exchange for not reclaiming Ruskowski, but Hawks GM Bob Pulford reneged and reclaimed both. Ruskowski was protected in the expansion draft, Hull wasn't, and Ferguson claimed Hull back from the Black Hawks in retaliation. He planned to trade Hull back to the Hawks for one of Preston or Ruskowski but Pulford refused, stating that younger players like Preston and Ruskowski were too high a price for the 40-year-old, semi-retired Hull. Ferguson and Pulford negotiated throughout the summer, but no deal could be reached. Ferguson tried to get Ruskowski back by claiming that according to NHL rules the Jets were owed compensation for the Hawks' signing of Preston (this was what Dale McCourt's lawsuit I mentioned earlier was about), and Ferguson wanted Ruskowski; Preston signed his contract immediately following the WHA playoffs and the signing was ruled to be not subject to 'equalization'.
Hull had no intention of playing for the Jets but he eventually relented, came out of retirement in November and played 18 games with the Jets before injuring a shoulder. Toward the end of February, 1980, after Hull recuperated from his injury, Ferguson traded him to the Whalers (complicated by the fact that Hull still owned 12.5% of the Jets; his share, worth approximately $430,000 at the time, was held in trust and Hull had no active role in the management of the Jets. The share was divested in the summer of 1980 as part of his divorce settlement with ex-wife Joanne). Ferguson and Hull reputedly had a very poor working relationship, and Ferguson often openly criticized Hull's play in the local media. Hull closed out his long, illustrious career in Hartford.
As I wrote in the notes above, Bengt Gustafsson was one of Edmonton's priority selections (the Oilers were the only team to use all of their available priority selections; the other teams only picked one skater each), however he was ultimately transferred to the Capitals. At issue was a directive the NHL gave the WHA during the merger negotiations: the WHA clubs were to cease all contract negotiations with players effective December 31, 1978 in order to prevent them from stocking up on players in anticipation of the merger. According to Oilers GM Larry Gordon the WHA didn't notify the member clubs' general managers of this directive until March of '79, after the merger was agreed upon. The Oilers signed Gustafsson after the December 31 cutoff date thus NHL President John Ziegler, after the Capitals presented this evidence to him, overruled the Oilers priority claim and transferred Gustafsson to the Capitals on Sept. 15, 1979. This was well after the expansion draft and the reclaim 'draft' so the Oilers had lost Gustafsson and the opportunity to reclaim someone else in his place.
Gustafsson was the only player whose rights were caught in this legal loophole. Goalie Hannu Kamppuri was signed by the Oilers in March of '79, and nobody had a problem with that...
Protected Lists
As I said earlier the NHL teams were allowed to protect up to 15 skaters and two goaltenders and would lose four players in the expansion draft, subject to an exception: if a team lost more than one of its reclaimed players as a priority selection it was allowed to protect an additional player. If a team lost two reclaims as priority selections it was allowed to protect 16 skaters and two goaltenders, and would lose only three players in the draft. If a team lost three reclaims as priority selections it was allowed to protect 17 skaters and two goaltenders, and would lose only two players in the draft. Just such a thing happened to the Penguins and Islanders. The Penguins reclaimed Paul Baxter, Kim Clackson and Morris Lukowich but Baxter and Lukowich were made priority selections by their respective WHA 'expansion' clubs. The Penguins were therefore allowed to protect an extra skater and would only lose three players in the expansion draft. The Islanders lost Richard Brodeur, Markus Mattsson and Garry Lariviere as priority selections therefore they were allowed to protect two extra skaters, and would only lose two players in the expansion draft.
The protected lists were filed on June 11, two days after the reclamation 'draft' and two days before the expansion draft.
Atlanta Flames | Boston Bruins | Buffalo Sabres | Chicago Black Hawks | Colorado Rockies | Detroit Red Wings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Dan Bouchard | Gerry Cheevers | Don Edwards | Murray Bannerman | Bill Oleschuk | Jim Rutherford |
Reggie Lemelin | Gilles Gilbert | Bob Sauve | Tony Esposito | Michel Plasse | Rogie Vachon |
Ivan Boldirev | Wayne Cashman | Ken Breitenbach | J.P. Bordeleau | Don Ashby | Thommie Bergman |
Guy Chouinard | Dwight Foster | Rick Dudley | Ted Bulley | Barry Beck | Dan Bolduc |
Bill Clement | Stan Jonathan | Danny Gare | Alain Daigle | Mike Christie | John Hilworth |
Ken Houston | Don Marcotte | Bill Hajt | Greg Fox | Gary Croteau | Billl Hogaboam |
Ed Kea | Peter McNab | Jerry Korab | Reg Kerr | Ron Delorme | Greg Joly |
Don Laurence | Rick Middleton | Don Luce | Cliff Koroll | Mike Dwyer | Dan Labraaten |
Bob MacMillan | Mike Milbury | Rick Martin | Dave Logan | Trevor Johansen | Reed Larson |
Bob Murdoch | Bob Miller | Gilbert Perreault | Tom Lysiak | Mike Kitchen | Nick Libett |
Kent Nilsson | Terry O'Reilly | Craig Ramsay | John Marks | Bill Lochead | Barry Long |
Willi Plett | Brad Park | Rene Robert | Grant Mulvey | Dennis Owchar | George Lyle |
Jean Pronovost | Jean Ratelle | Andre Savard | Bob Murray | Wilf Paiement | Perry Miller |
Darcy Rota | Dick Redmond | Jim Schoenfeld | Harold Phillipoff | Randy Pierce | Dennis Polonich |
Phil Russell | Bobby Schmautz | Dave Schultz | Pat Ribble | Don Saleski | Andre St. Laurent |
Dave Shand | Rick Smith | Ric Seiling | Terry Ruskowski | Jack Valiquette | Errol Thompson |
Eric Vail | John Wensink | Derek Smith | Doug Wilson | John Van Boxmeer | Paul Woods |
Los Angeles Kings | Minnesota North Stars | Montreal Canadiens | New York Islanders | New York Rangers | Philadelphia Flyers |
Ron Grahame | Gary Edwards | Ken Dryden | Chico Resch | John Davidson | Rick St. Croix |
Mario Lessard | Gilles Meloche | Michel Larocque | Billy Smith | Doug Soetaert | Phil Myre |
Marcel Dionne | Kent-Erik Andersson | Brian Engblom | Mike Bossy | Lucien DeBlois | Bill Barber |
Glenn Goldup | Fred Barrett | Bob Gainey | Bob Bourne | Ron Duguay | Mel Bridgman |
Butch Goring | Per-Olov Brasar | Rejean Houle | Clark Gillies | Phil Esposito | Bobby Clarke |
Rick Hampton | Jack Carlson | Doug Jarvis | Bill Harris | Ron Greschner | Bob Dailey |
Randy Holt | Mike Fidler | Guy Lafleur | Lorne Henning | Anders Hedberg | Andre Dupont |
Steve Jensen | Al MacAdam | Yvon Lambert | Mike Hordy | Pat Hickey | Paul Evans |
Randy Manery | Kris Manery | Guy Lapointe | Garry Howatt | Dave Maloney | Tom Gorence |
Rick Mulhern | Brad Maxwell | Jacques Lemaire | Mike Kaszycki | Mario Marois | Al Hill |
Mike Murphy | Gary Sargent | Pierre Mondou | Dave Langevin | Mike McEwen | Paul Holmgren |
Rob Palmer | Glen Sharpley | Mark Napier | Dave Lewis | Don Murdoch | Bob "Hound Dog" Kelly |
Charlie Simmer | Paul Shmyr | Doug Risebrough | Bob Lorimer | Ulf Nilsson | Reggie Leach |
Dave Taylor | Greg Smith | Larry Robinson | Wayne Merrick | Dean Talafous | Rick MacLeish |
Vic Venasky | Tim Young | Serge Savard | Bob Nystrom | Walt Tkaczuk | Terry Murray |
Bert Wilson | Tom Younghans | Steve Shutt | Stefan Persson | Carol Vadnais | Dennis Ververgaert |
Murray Wilson | Ron Zanussi | Mario Tremblay | Denis Potvin | Steve Vickers | Jim Watson |
John Tonelli | |||||
Bryan Trottier | |||||
Pittsburgh Penguins | St. Louis Blues | Toronto Maple Leafs | Vancouver Canucks | Washington Capitals | |
Denis Herron | Mike Liut | Paul Harrison | Gary Bromley | Jim Bedard | |
Gord Laxton | Ed Staniowski | Mike Palmateer | Glen Hanlon | Gary Inness | |
Russ Anderson | Jack Brownschilde | John Anderson | Jeff Bandura | Pierre Bouchard | |
Tom Bladon | Mike Crombeen | Pat Boutette | Rick Blight | Guy Charron | |
Randy Carlyle | Tony Currie | Dave Burrows | Drew Callander | Steve Clippingdale | |
Blair Chapman | Blake Dunlop | Jerry Butler | Brad Gassoff | Rick Green | |
George Ferguson | Bernie Federko | Paul Gardner | Jere Gillis | Dennis Hextall | |
Jim Hamilton | Neil Labatte | Dave Hutchison | John Hughes | Yvon Labre | |
Rick Kehoe | Rick Lapointe | Dan Maloney | Dennis Kearns | Gord Lane | |
Orest Kindrachuk | Chuck Lefley | Lanny McDonald | Don Lever | Mark Lofthouse | |
Peter Lee | Bryan Maxwell | Walt McKechnie | Bob Manno | Jack Lynch | |
Ross Lonsberry | Larry Patey | Rocky Saganiuk | Kevin McCarthy | Dennis Maruk | |
Pete Mahovlich | Tom Roulston | Borje Salming | Jack McIlhargey | Robert Picard | |
Greg Malone | Bob Stewart | Darryl Sittler | Chris Oddleifson | Greg Polis | |
Gary McAdam | Brian Sutter | Ian Turnbull | Ron Sedibauer | Tom Rowe | |
Rod Schutt | Garry Unger | Dave Williams | Harold Snepsts | Peter Scamurra | |
Gregg Sheppard | Mike Zuke | Ron Wilson | Bob Tudor | Bob Sirois | |
Ron Stackhouse |
The Draft
Overall | Player Chosen | By | From | Fill-In |
---|---|---|---|---|
Round 1 | ||||
1 | Peter Marsh | Winnipeg Jets | Montreal Canadiens | Bill Nyrop |
2 | Cam Connor | Edmonton Oilers | Montreal Canadiens | Gilles Lupien |
3 | Alan Hangsleben | Hartford Whalers | Montreal Canadiens | Rod Langway |
4 | Dave Farrish | Quebec Nordiques | New York Rangers | Jocelyn Guevremont |
Round 2 | ||||
5 | Gerry Hart | Quebec Nordiques | New York Islanders | Yvon Vautour |
6 | Nick Fotiu | Hartford Whalers | New York Rangers | Ed Johnstone |
7 | Lee Fogolin | Edmonton Oilers | Buffalo Sabres | Bill Stewart |
8 | Lindsay Middlebrook | Winnipeg Jets | New York Rangers | |
Round 3 | ||||
9 | Bobby Hull | Winnipeg Jets | Chicago Black Hawks | Bob Hoffmeyer |
10 | Pat Price | Edmonton Oilers | New York Islanders | |
11 | Rick Ley | Hartford Whalers | Toronto Maple Leafs | Jimmy Jones |
12 | Ron Low | Quebec Nordiques | Detroit Red Wings | |
Round 4 | ||||
13 | Pierre Plante | Quebec Nordiques | New York Rangers | Jim Mayer |
14 | Al Sims | Hartford Whalers | Boston Bruins | Gary Doak |
15 | Colin Campbell | Edmonton Oilers | Pittsburgh Penguins | Kim Clackson |
16 | Al Cameron | Winnipeg Jets | Detroit Red Wings | Jean Hamel |
Round 5 | ||||
17 | Dave Hoyda | Winnipeg Jets | Philadelphia Flyers | Barry Dean |
18 | Larry Brown | Edmonton Oilers | Los Angeles Kings | Doug Halward |
19 | Jean Savard | Hartford Whalers | Chicago Black Hawks | Miles Zaharko |
20 | Blair Stewart | Quebec Nordiques | Washington Capitals | Eddy Godin |
Round 6 | ||||
21 | John Baby | Quebec Nordiques | Minnesota North Stars | Dave Semenko |
22 | Ralph Klassen | Hartford Whalers | Colorado Rockies | John Contini |
23 | Pete LoPresti | Edmonton Oilers | Minnesota North Stars | |
24 | Jim Roberts | Winnipeg Jets | Minnesota North Stars | Dan Chicoine |
Round 7 | ||||
25 | Lorne Stamler | Winnipeg Jets | Toronto Maple Leafs | Ron Ellis |
26 | Ron Areshenkoff | Edmonton Oilers | Buffalo Sabres | Richie Dunn |
27 | Rick Hodgson | Hartford Whalers | Atlanta Flames | Bobby Lalonde |
28 | John Smrke | Quebec Nordiques | St. Louis Blues | Bob Murdoch |
Round 8 | ||||
29 | Dave Parro | Quebec Nordiques | Boston Bruins | |
30 | Kevin Kemp | Hartford Whalers | Toronto Maple Leafs | Bruce Boudreau |
31 | Inge Hammarstrom | Edmonton Oilers | St. Louis Blues | Neil Komadoski |
32 | Mark Heaslip | Winnipeg Jets | Los Angeles Kings | Darryl Edestrand |
Round 9 | ||||
33 | Pierre Hamel | Winnipeg Jets | Toronto Maple Leafs | |
34 | John Gould | Edmonton Oilers | Atlanta Flames | Curt Bennett |
35 | Bill Bennett | Hartford Whalers | Boston Bruins | Dennis O'Brien |
36 | Ken Kuzyk | Quebec Nordiques | Minnesota North Stars | |
Round 10 | ||||
37 | Roland Cloutier | Quebec Nordiques | Detroit Red Wings | Rick Vasko |
38 | Bernie Johnston | Hartford Whalers | Philadelphia Flyers | Dennis Sobchuk |
39 | Doug Hicks | Edmonton Oilers | Chicago Black Hawks | Keith Magnuson |
40 | Gord McTavish | Winnipeg Jets | St. Louis Blues | Bob Simpson |
Round 11 | ||||
41 | Gord Smith | Winnipeg Jets | Washington Capitals | Bob Girard |
42 | Tom Edur | Edmonton Oilers | Pittsburgh Penguins | Dale Tallon |
43 | Brian Hill | Hartford Whalers | Atlanta Flames | Brad Marsh |
44 | Terry Martin | Quebec Nordiques | Buffalo Sabres | Larry Playfair |
Round 12 | ||||
45 | Jamie Masters | Quebec Nordiques | St. Louis Blues | |
46 | David Given | Hartford Whalers | Buffalo Sabres | |
47 | Wayne Bianchin | Edmonton Oilers | Pittsburgh Penguins | |
48 | Clark Hamilton | Winnipeg Jets | Detroit Red Wings | |
Round 13 | ||||
49 | Jim Cunningham | Winnipeg Jets | Philadelphia Flyers | Gord Garbutt |
50 | Mike Forbes | Edmonton Oilers | Boston Bruins | |
51 | M.F. Schurman | Hartford Whalers | Philadelphia Flyers | |
52 | Hartland Monahan | Quebec Nordiques | Los Angeles Kings | Steve Carlson |
Round 14 | ||||
53 | Ron Andruff | Quebec Nordiques | Colorado Rockies | Larry Skinner |
54 | Nick Beverley | Hartford Whalers | Colorado Rockies | Mike Gillis |
55 | Doug Favell | Edmonton Oilers | Colorado Rockies | |
56 | Dennis Abgrall | Winnipeg Jets | Los Angeles Kings | |
Round 15 | ||||
57 | Bill Riley | Winnipeg Jets | Washington Capitals | Ron Lalonde |
58 | Doug Patey | Edmonton Oilers | Washington Capitals | |
59 | Norm Lapointe | Hartford Whalers | Vancouver Canucks | |
60 | Alain Cote | Quebec Nordiques | Montreal Canadiens | |
Round 16 | ||||
61 | Lars Zetterstrom | Quebec Nordiques | Vancouver Canucks | Larry Goodenough |
62 | Don Kozak | Hartford Whalers | Vancouver Canucks | |
63 | Bob "Battleship" Kelly | Edmonton Oilers | Chicago Black Hawks | |
64 | Gene Carr | Winnipeg Jets | Atlanta Flames | |
Round 17 | ||||
65 | Hilliard Graves | Winnipeg Jets | Vancouver Canucks |
Backroom Deals
You might look at the first round's results and think "Hmm, that's an awfully strange coincidence that the first three picks were all from the Canadiens, and the expansion teams passed up chances to pick up someone like Rod Langway." It's not coincidence, it was Montreal Canadiens GM Irv Grundman pulling his best Sam Pollock impression. If you've read my post about the 1967 Expansion Draft you may recall that Sam Pollock was the man who wrote the rules for that draft and who crafted exemptions so that he could keep many of his best young players. Grundman, Pollock's successor, wheeled-and-dealed as best he could 12 years later.
The first round of results was essentially pre-arranged. If you scroll up to the list of players available for reclaim you'll notice many, many Canadiens players. And yet the Canadiens only reclaimed four players: Alain Côté, Danny Geoffrion, Peter Marsh and Alan Hangsleben. They took those four in particular because they were manipulating the expansion teams to pick the players they wanted them to pick. In consideration for picking the players the Canadiens wanted them to pick the four new teams would be allowed to keep the players the Canadiens could have otherwise reclaimed. Montreal reclaimed Côté and Geoffrion from Quebec because they wanted Geoffrion, didn't want Côté, and wanted Quebec to lay off from picking Langway, Rick Chartraw, Pierre Larouche or another player the Canadiens were intent on keeping. For this Quebec was allowed to keep Marc Tardif, J.C. Tremblay, Barry Melrose, John Stewart, etc.
Similarly Montreal 'gifted' Dave Hunter (who was a highly regarded prospect at the time; the Habs' first-round pick in 1978, in fact) to the Oilers as long as they went along with the plan and picked Cam Connor. Winnipeg got to keep Peter Marsh and Jamie Hislop, and Hartford got to keep Hangsleben and Gordie Roberts.
The Nordiques were also keen on keeping Real Cloutier, their leading scorer at the time, but his NHL rights were owned by the Black Hawks. The Hawks had much more interest in Cloutier than they did in any of the players they were leaving unprotected, so Quebec had to cough up a first round entry draft pick to keep the Hawks from reclaiming Cloutier. This trade became infamous because the pick the Nordiques gave up, their first round pick in 1980, was eventually a #3 overall pick used by the Hawks to select Denis Savard. Cloutier was a very skilled player and still not even 23 years old at the time, but he retired at age 28; Savard played for 17 years and became a Hall of Famer.
In other such deals the North Stars traded a fourth round draft pick to the Oilers in exchange for the Oilers letting the North Stars reclaim Paul Shmyr. The pick was used to select Glenn Anderson. Similarly the Jets got a seventh round pick from the Penguins for letting the Penguins have Kim Clackson; the pick was used to select winger Mike Lauen, who played a grand total of three games in his entire NHL career. Not quite the steal that the Oilers ended up with.
The Islanders reclaimed goalie Richard Brodeur from the Nordiques but the Nordiques made Brodeur one of their priority selections. The Isles still wanted Brodeur so they traded third-stringer Goran Hogosta to the Nordiques for Brodeur. Brodeur had been the Nordiques' starter and in retrospect they probably should have kept him. Hogosta played part of one season with the Nordiques before going back to Sweden, while Brodeur was eventually traded to the Canucks and was the driving force behind the Canucks' trip to the Stanley Cup Finals in 1982. I guess the Nordiques were confident in former Cincinnati Stinger Michel Dion, whom they acquired in the WHA dispersal draft.
The Edmonton Oilers were hardest hit by player reclamation, losing 14 players to NHL clubs (15 if you count Bengt Gustafsson). They reacquired Dave Semenko (trivia note: Semenko, unlikely as it may seem, scored the very last goal in WHA history; at 19:48 of the third period of game six of the finals Semenko potted the third goal in a 7-3 defeat. Click here for a video! You can hear Rich Preston's speech at the end too!) and received a third round draft pick from the North Stars in August, 1979 for the Oilers' second and third round picks. The pick the Oilers received was used to select Mark Messier, while the picks the North Stars received were used to select Neal Broten and Kevin Maxwell. The Oilers also reacquired Risto Siltanen from the Blues, along with Tom Roulston, in exchange for Joe Micheletti.
A connection between Wayne Gretzky and Montreal Canadiens genius GM Sam Pollock? Its September, 1976. Wayne had just completed a season with the Junior B Toronto Nationals as a 15 year old. Sam knew then that Wayne would be a superstar. Pollock was well known for his wheeling and dealing to secure Guy Lafleur in 1971 and Steve Shutt in 1972 (he failed to pry the first pick overall in 1973- Denis Potvin- from the New York Islanders despite many offers to Islanders Bill Torrey. Wayne by virtue of his birthdate would have been eligible for the 1980 Entry Draft. So Sam had to think of a way to own the #1 pick overall that year. The Kansas City Scouts franchise had just folded after a miserable season (on ice and in attendance) and moved to Denver as the Colorado Rockies. Ray Miron was the GM and before the Rockies attended training camp Sam convinced him to take Ron Andruff and Sean Shanahan in exchange for the option to switch first round picks in the 1980 Entry Draft. As it turned out, due to 1979 Expansion provisions Gretzky remained with Edmonton and the Rockies were the worst team in the 1979-80 season. Pollock exercised his option and the Canadiens chose Doug Wickenheiser #1 overall over local francophone hero Denis Savard. Wayne turned out to be the superstar Sam envisioned four years earlier.
ReplyDeleteI've heard this anecdote before, about Sam Pollock being so prescient about Gretzky that he got the option for the Rockies pick four years before he'd need it. It's an interesting story but there's one little hiccup in it that makes it unbelievable to me: if the rules of the draft were the same in the early '80s as they had been before Gretzky wouldn't have been eligible for selection until 1981. The cut-off date for eligibility in the Amateur Draft was January 1st of the calendar year 19 years before the year of the draft—e.g. in 1976 players born before January 1, 1957 were eligible for selection. If the rules had stayed the same the cutoff in the 1980 draft would would have been January 1, 1961. Gretzky's birthday is January 26.
DeleteThere is a great hockey website that has been revived after a long dormant period: hockeydraftcentral.com. Under the 1980 draft page is a section called "The Basics":
DeleteEligible For Draft: All amateur players born between January 1, 1960, and September 15, 1962.
Yes, but the draft eligibility rules changed in 1979. At the time that Sam Pollock made the trade for the Rockies' draft pick—1976—Gretzky would not have been eligible for the draft until '81. So the idea that Pollock knew about Gretzky and was planning years in advance is a little fanciful.
DeleteI think the Islanders leaving Gerry Hart unprotected as part of pre-draft condition for them to reacquire Richard Brodeur.
ReplyDeleteAbout Robbie Ftorek ending up with the Nordiques... Nordiques President Marcel Aubut didn't want to agree to the "2 skaters and 2 goalies protected" rule. He probably threaten to make the expansion derail. So, the other 3 owners "gave" Ftorek to the Nordiques to shut him up and agree to the merger.
ReplyDeleteAbout Louis Sleigher, he was contracted with the Nordiques in 1979, not 1980. http://www.histoirenordiques.ca/statscartessleigherl.html